Why no Tariff Inflation?
And Why Haven't they Yet
We’ve seen essentially zero tariff inflation after 4 months.
Jerome Powell keeps warning it's right around the corner. While Secretary Bessent claims tariffs “cannot” cause inflation.
So who's right.
Inflation and Tariffs
In a recent interview with Larry Kudlow, Treasury Secretary Bessent claimed tariffs "cannot be inflationary."
Because unless you're printing money, when the price of one thing goes up the price of everything else goes down since people have less money to spend on the other stuff.
So it's squeezing a balloon -- tariff-pumped Chinese socks take money from your Taco Bell budget. Socks go up, Taco Supremes go down.
The formal term would be price reallocation under a hard money constraint.
And here’s an example from 2018: PCE inflation went up for tariffed goods, but it dropped for non-tariffed “core” goods.
So does that mean tariffs cannot increase inflation?
In economics there's almost always a difference between short-run and long-run. Because it takes time for companies -- and consumers -- to react.
For example, if you put a hundred percent tariff on Chinese socks it's instant. But Taco Bell will take time to notice the drop in demand from its socks-impoverished customers.
Then it'll take time to decide what do do about it: Will the drop in demand last, is it worth cutting prices and losing customer goodwill and market share.
So socks go up fast. Taco Bell goes down slow.
The Long-Run
But in the long run Bessent is largely correct -- once everybody adjusts, tariffs squeeze the balloon. Imports go up, everything else gets cheaper.
Including, by the way, Made in America stuff that competes with imports.
Only “largely” correct because even in the long-run you have a permanent hunk of inflation in the form of tariff revenue paid to government.
As in, it's a balloon, but part of the air leaked to federal tariff revenue.
In fact, tariffs could be deflationary if they boost domestic production enough. Because at that point you’ve got more stuff for dollars to chase -- the opposite of inflation, which is more money chasing goods.
Note that this is all theory -- short-term inflation that fades in the long-term, potentially into deflation.
Because at the moment, we're not even seeing short-run tariff inflation. Instead, Chinese and Japanese are eating the tariffs by lowering their prices, just as they did in 2018.
This is probably tactical, as in they don't expect tariffs to last. So they don't want to hike prices and risk losing market share.
But once we do get settled tariff deals — if ever — expect price hikes initially, easing in the long run potentially into deflation.
The Size of the Balloon
Through all of this, note what's doing the real inflation work here: The size of the balloon. Which is the money supply.
About a fifth of the M2 money supply is literally printing money at the Fed -- typing zeros on a spreadsheet and using it to buy government bonds so Congress can waste it.
But the rest of the balloon is commercial banks pyramiding on that typed-up base money. Banks literally magicking up the money for your mortgage, credit card, or business loan.
Now, under Trump, M2's actually been rising faster than Biden, driven by rising bank loans. The balloon’s getting bigger.
It takes time to filter through to inflation -- that short-run vs long-run thing again. But given government spending isn't going down — nor is the Fed’s willingness to finance it — the balloon will keep getting bigger.
And inflation will follow.
What’s Next
Tariff inflation will be transitory -- if we get it at all.
Even the Fed admits this.
But the larger issue is Congress' failure to cut spending means the Bidenflation balloon is back to growing.
Toss in bank lending that always rises in a boom and we could see inflation start to see inflation grind up through the year. Not from tariffs but from Congress' trillion-dollar gaping wound of red ink.
The only way to outrun that is grow production faster -- something like 3 or 4% GDP growth to soak up the freshly printed money.
If not, we will get inflation. And it will have little to do with tariffs.
.
Every week I write an article on Economics and Freedom here on Prof St Onge Weekly.
Subscribe to get each article in your inbox.
I also make short daily videos on economics and freedom:
Roundup Podcast of the week’s videos on Spotify, Apple, and Google
Services inflation is out of control. The haircut that was 25 last July is now 35. The acupuncture session that was 42 last July is now 50. The deductible at the Chiropractor is now 20, last July it was 15. The $100 oil change is now $120. The list is endless.
It’s all crap. Actual inflation, the real destruction of purchasing power that people feel at the end of the month is running 8-12% per year. And has been since 2019.
Whether they are retired or not, 90% live on an income that is fixed. And the actual purchasing power of that income has been literally and figuratively obliterated over the past 5 years. The fact that the 15,000 Viking stove your wife covers is the same price as a year ago is irrelevant to the rest of us.
Interest rates need to go up. Not down. Govt measured inflation has now been above the 2% target for nearly 5 straight years. Every month of those years.
Oh. And BTW. The amended Fed Reserve Act of 1977 mandates “stable prices”. To every person with an IQ above 50 (except bureaucrats and academics) stable prices means zero. Not 2%
Powell should be fired. But not for his ‘failure’ to
Lower rates.
I respect your work. But you are not dealing in reality.
Depends on how inflation is measured. We cannot trust what the government says or what the goons at the Fed say. On my trip to the local Wallyville yesterday, the shelves are well stocked (all around the store) and thus the supply of goods appears to be buoyant.
I recall many saying that there will be no goods from China in the stores. However, food prices are still rising. I expect my rent to go up another 10% by the end of the year. Medical services sure aren't getting cheaper. Car repairs? Give me a break. Inflation strictly depends upon the level and type of goods and services you need and consume as an individual. There is NO one size fits all.